Doctoral student Hannah Wagganer has big dreams of leaving her hometown of Glen Arbor behind to teach at a large university. That is, until Jasper Morgan, the new mail carrier, arrives in town. Not only does he send Hannahâ€™s heart racing, but he creates an instant bond with her cat, Jingles.
While Hannah is busy preparing for the churchâ€™s candlelight Christmas Eve service and running the family store, she keeps bumping into Jasperâ€”right in front of the prying eyes of the locals, who suspect thereâ€™s more going on than business as usual.
But then, a series of unexpected blessings occurs that changes the townâ€™s focus: first, an anonymous donor pays to have the church furnace repaired, and then other locals suddenly find solutions to their problems. Is it coincidental, or the work of a secret angel?