Liam Yoder has been leading a double life since he was a teenager. When his father dies in a buggy accident, he feels torn between the English life he craves and the Amish life in which he was raised.

After a chance meeting with Lucy Graber, the Amish love he’d left behind seven years before, Liam is faced with the biggest decision of his life. Does he return to the Amish community and his family, or will he choose to stay among the English? Find out in this bittersweet love story.